This is a disturbing story on more levels than can be counted. First we have a homeless mother trying to do the best she can for a young child and his education who has no choice in his current circumstances. The mother wants her child to get a better education- perhaps to avoid having the same fate of homelessness fall on her…
We often read stories about parents who are down and out sitting home, watching TV and being totally irresponsible. Such is not the case here with Tanya McDowell and the response? Condemnation and outright callousness. They are claiming she’s stealing services..This story breaks your heart and unfortunately seems to be happening more and more. It was just a few months ago we read about a mother in Akron, Ohio facing similar charges of fraud..
What’s even more troubling is this sort of thing has happened 4 other times this year, but no charges were brought on the parents who falsified residency information. Why is this happening now?
Outrage around homeless mom charged for sending son to better school
By Liz Goodwin
Education activists are rallying around a homeless woman who may face jail time for enrolling her son in kindergarten under a friend’s address. Supporters say the woman’s story is yet another dismaying example of inequality in the U.S. education system.
Tanya McDowell, a homeless single mother from Bridgeport, is charged with first-degree larceny and conspiracy to commit first-degree larceny for signing up her 5-year-old son to attend nearby Norwalk schools under the address of a friend. (Her son went to the school for four months. Her friend has been evicted from public housing for letting McDowell use her address.) McDowell may face up to 20 years in prison and a $15,000 fine if convicted.
Gwen Samuel, a Connecticut education activist, is organizing a press conference to try to get the charges dropped and raise awareness about parents who are criminally prosecuted, rather than dealt with individually by the school district, for using false addresses.
She says she expects a few hundred people to show up at Norwalk superior court at 9 a.m. Wednesday, including Kelley Williams-Bolar (pictured), the Akron, Ohio-based mom who made national news in January, when she was jailed for using her father’s address to send her kids to a better-performing school. Bolar’s story ignited a debate about inequalities in the public education system, where poorer parents must send their kids to poorer schools because much of the funding is on the local level.
“This will continue to happen–this will set a precedent and districts will be like, ‘OK I found a new way to get my money back, let’s go after them,'” Samuel tells The Lookout.
Boyce Watkins, a Syracuse university professor and activist, tells The Lookout that Williams-Bolar heard about McDowell’s case and wanted to support her. “Kelley called me and said, ‘I can’t believe they’re doing this to her, how can I help?'” She’s now on her way to Connecticut, and her trip is paid for by Samuel’s newly founded non-profit Connecticut Parents Union.
“First it happens to Kelley, then it happens to Tanya–they both happen to be poor black mothers trying to find a way to provide a better life for their children,” Watkins said.
Samuel says McDowell “absolutely” sent her son to the Norwalk kindergarten because she knew it was better than the schools in nearby Bridgeport. “If you could see … where he is now compared to Brookside, you’d see why I chose Norwalk,” McDowell told the Daily Norwalk of her son’s new school, Thomas Hooker Elementary School in Bridgeport.
“There has to be a penalty for stealing our services,” school board president Jack Chiaramonte countered in The Daily Norwalk.
McDowell, who used to work in food services, told the Stamford Advocate she occasionally stayed in a Norwalk homeless shelter–but she didn’t register there, which would have made her son eligible to attend the school. “I had no idea whatsoever that if you enroll your child in another school district, it becomes a crime,” the 33-year-old told the paper.
Parents are rarely criminally prosecuted for using false addresses.
A parent should have the opportunity to send their child to a quality school without repercussions (e.g. jail time is overboard) and a fair and clear rules/guidelines that allow such action to occur. Ironic is that the San Francisco Unified School District has been cracking down on parents using dual or false addresses as a way to get their kids into schools such as Lowell H.S. (notorious track record for being exclusive to Asian to keep scores high). There are mixed emotions about this and other situations, but if school choice vouchers (similar in practice as housing choice vouchers) were in play without all of the politics and usual suspect hording educational funds for failed models, more kids would have an opportunity towards better education. Also, there must be stronger accountability and responsiblity of everyone including parents school boards, administrators and local politicians in improving and providing a better environment for kids to learn and grow in.
P.S – Davey D., where you been for the month of April? Missed reading your blogs on a regular basis.
Cosign with F.W. Lee.
Also, welcome back Davey.
First and foremost, when the hell did education become a service???????????
Secondly, you mean to tell me that they plan on sending a “Homeless Mother” to jail for trying to provide positive stablility for her child while dealing with a negative living situation, Really, so what about the child?
Has technology taken us so far away from being human that we as a society can do something so heartless to someone trying to raise a child Responsibly the best way she can…..I mean that is somewhat the definition of a parent,right?
I am so glad I live in Australia. This would not happen over here. If the child was accepted into the school irrespective of where the mother resided, then that child would stay enrolled. The school would also help put the mother in contact with all the services they could so that she could get affordable accommodation for herself and her child, and the se services would help her to either get a job or into adult education so that she could get a better life! Where is this school’s sense of community and social responsibility? Considering this mother and child are homeless, why do they automatically get put into the poorer school district? Smacks of social snobbery to me! Shame on you America
this illustrates everything which is wrong with America.
This article (amongst many other things) should be used to show all those IMBECILES who frivolously think we live in a post-racial country, that ain’t a damn thing changed. This Sista is actually being a responsible parent, but she’s getting an unjustified backhand from the 7-headed dragon, and it also shows how poor people, especially poor Black people, always get the worst of the worst- but the media has the audacity to think that the middle class has it bad, right????? I also proudly co-sign what F.W. Lee said.
The situation is sad & silly…:/
These are signs of a crumbling empire!
What would have happened if she told them she didn’t have an address because she’s homeless?, that she and her son slept in the park of that town, would that have been in their district? It would have been but they probably would have turned her into child protective services, her son would be taken away from her, and no matter what school he ended up in his morale and separation anxiety from his Mother would have kicked in and he wouldn’t be able to function, never mind learn anything. This country is on it’s way out and ppl better wake up…..
Pingback: A Look Back at Some Dubious, Shocking or Outlandish Moments of 2011 | Davey D-Hip Hop Culture-Hip Hop Politics
Pingback: A Look Back at Some of the Most Dubious, Shocking & Outlandish Moments of 2011 | Davey D-Hip Hop Culture-Hip Hop Politics
Pingback: A Look back at Some of the Most Dubious & Outlandish Moments of 2011 « Davey D's Hip Hop Corner-(The Blog)